
Hey everyone, DennisCW here! If you've been following the ongoing debate between electric vehicles (EVs) and internal combustion engine (ICE) cars, you've probably come across some wild claims about battery life and replacement costs. In one of my recent videos, I dove deep into this topic, sparked by a viral post that got a lot of attention. Today, I'm breaking it down in this blog post, plus sharing some essential Tesla accessories that every owner needs. Let's get into it!
I was surprised to learn that a brand-new Tesla Model Y battery costs around $15,000. At first glance, that might seem steep, but when you stack it up against replacing an entire ICE engine, it's actually pretty comparable—and often more affordable in the long run.
The conversation started with a post from Jordan, who argued: "In 5 to 10 years, you have to replace your EV battery at 60 to 70% of the cost of your entire car, 30-40K. While ICE will simply need a $80 oil change. That's why EVs will never replace ICE cars. As simple as that. Not everyone earns 100K a year to afford a car of toys."
It's a fair point on the surface, but let's unpack this. ICE engines don't always last forever either—many require major repairs or full replacements over time, which can easily run into thousands of dollars. Plus, those routine oil changes add up, not to mention other maintenance like transmission work or exhaust system fixes.
Enter Wes, one of the chief engineers on the Cybertruck team, who chimed in with some facts: "The correct info is available to anyone who wants to find it on tesla.com. Tesla offers an 8-year, 120,000-mile battery warranty, and the cost of a new battery is $15,000."
That's straight from the source! And now, with Tesla's parts.tesla.com site, you can look up retail prices for batteries and other components yourself. Keep in mind, this $15,000 figure is for a new battery and might not include labor costs for installation.
But here's where it gets even better: There are plenty of independent shops that can repair, refurbish, or install used batteries from salvaged Teslas at a fraction of the cost—I've seen options as low as $6,000 to $7,000. So, replacement isn't always a wallet-busting ordeal.
A lot of new Tesla owners ask me: "Should I be worried about the battery? Should I only charge to 80%?" My advice? If you're within the 8-year, 120,000-mile warranty (or even the Cybertruck's 150,000-mile version), you've got nothing to stress about. Tesla's got you covered.
That said, EV owners tend to upgrade vehicles more frequently due to rapid tech advancements—much like swapping out your iPhone every couple of years. By the time warranty expires, you might be ready for the next model anyway!
What are your thoughts? Have you replaced a battery, or are you holding off on an EV because of these concerns? Drop a comment below—I'd love to hear from you.
Now, shifting gears: Did you know your new Tesla comes with zero accessories? Not even a basic phone mount! But don't sweat it—I've got recommendations from my trusted partner, Joa, whose products I use every day.
Here are my top must-haves:
Joa offers way more than the basics, too—like a wireless game controller that tucks neatly into the glove box, a portable air compressor for road trip peace of mind, and even an electric scooter to zip around from superchargers without walking.
The best part? Use my promo code (check the video description) to save money and support the channel. Plus, get free shipping on orders over $120. Head over to Joa's site via the link below—thanks to them for partnering with us!
EVs like the Tesla Model Y are more practical and cost-effective than the myths suggest, especially with solid warranties and affordable repair options. Pair that with some smart accessories, and you're set for an awesome ownership experience. If this post helped debunk some EV doubts or inspired your next purchase, give it a share!
Stay charged, folks—DennisCW out.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. Purchases made through them support the channel at no extra cost to you.
Tesla enthusiast and EV expert. Sharing tips on maximizing your Tesla ownership experience.