Will Used Tesla Prices Crash After Tax Credits End?

Will Used Tesla Prices Crash After Tax Credits End?

Hey everyone, DennisCW here! If you're in the market for a used Tesla or just keeping an eye on the EV scene, you've probably noticed some wild fluctuations in prices lately. In my latest video, I dove deep into whether used Tesla prices are about to crash now that key tax credits have expired. Spoiler: It depends on the model year and segment, but there's some surprising short-term appreciation happening too. Let's break it down with data, dealer insights, and real-world examples.

The End of EV Tax Credits: What Happened?

As of September 30th, the $7,500 federal tax credit for new EVs and the $4,000 used EV tax credit officially ended. This has left many buyers wondering: Will this cause used Tesla prices to plummet? The short answer is yes for some segments, but not all—and in fact, we're seeing the opposite in others.

For used Teslas in the $20,000–$25,000 range (think older models), prices were artificially inflated by that $4,000 credit. That's a huge percentage on a vehicle in this price bracket! Without it, demand is dropping, and dealers are already feeling the pinch. Expect these prices to crash as the hype dies down.

On the flip side, if you're looking at 1- to 2-year-old Teslas (like 2025 or 2026 models), prices might actually increase in the short term. Why? New Tesla MSRPs are higher without the $7,500 credit, making gently used models more attractive. Plus, not everyone qualifies for the credit anyway, so buyers are turning to the used market for better deals.

Real-World Example: My Friend's Model Y Sale

Take my friend Jose, for instance. He was selling his 2026 Tesla Model Y. Before the tax credit ended, he was getting lowball offers around $38,000–$40,000. But right after October 1st, bids jumped to $42,000–$43,000, and he closed the deal at $45,000! That's a $5,000 swing in just days. It's a clear sign that buyers are pivoting to used options now that new ones are pricier without incentives.

This won't last forever—depreciation will kick in eventually. But for now, it's creating a short-term bump for newer used Teslas.

Dealer Feedback: Mixed but Telling

I reached out to my network of dealers and got some great insights. Here's a quick roundup:

• Ted: Little impact on new car sales, but used vehicles under $25k will see softer prices due to lower demand.
• Pablo: Prices might drop slightly over time.
• James: Cars sold fine before credits existed, so it'll be okay.
• Manny: Buyers set prices, so they'll adjust downward to compensate.
• Alexa: Prices could rise on the new side with added perks like free Supercharging.

Overall, the consensus points to downward pressure on older models but stability or even gains for newer ones. Shoutout to Josh from Cheap Teslas for sparking this discussion!

Data Dive: What the Numbers Say

Looking at the CarGurus Index, used Tesla prices spiked unnaturally in the weeks leading up to the credit expiration—up 7–14% year-over-year for models like the Model Y. The overall used car market (gray line) stayed flat, but Tesla's blue line shot up. What goes up must come down, especially for those older vehicles. If you're eyeing a $25k Tesla, hold off—the drop is coming.

For newer models, we're seeing sales in the $45,000–$47,000 range, which isn't far off from what new ones cost with credits just a short while ago (around $37,000 after incentives).

Cool Tesla Upgrades and Tips

In other news, check out this awesome Nardo Gray wrap on a Model Y! It's a DIY colored PPF kit from Tesbros. If you're handy, you can save thousands by installing it yourself—options for front bumper, full frontal, or the whole car in clear, colored, or stealth finishes. Use my promo code link in the description for a discount!

Also, I just upgraded the wheels on my Cybertruck to the Cyber Nova from Unplugged Performance. They're more efficient and keep that green-with-gold vibe I love. Unplugged has cool options like the Road Warrior wheels with removable curbs (perfect for curb-rash prone drivers like me). They even offer a $1,000 trade-in credit for your stock wheels—ship from anywhere in the US!

Protect Your Credit Before Financing a Tesla

If you're planning to finance your next Tesla, protect your credit first. Bank of America recently had a data breach and waited a month to notify customers—your info could be out there right now. Most breaches take 277 days to report! That's why I use Aura, today's sponsor. It scans the dark web for your data, reduces spam calls, removes your info from broker sites, and includes $5 million in identity theft insurance—all in one app. Try it free for 14 days at aura.com/denniscw (link below).

Final Thoughts

Used Tesla prices are in flux: Older models are set to crash, while newer ones might appreciate short-term. What are you seeing in your local market? Drop a comment below if you're a buyer, seller, or dealer—I'd love to hear your take!

If you enjoyed this, hit that like button on the video and subscribe for more Tesla insights. Thanks for reading!

DennisCW