Tesla Insurance Costs Revealed: What 100+ Owners Pay by Model, Age, and Company

Tesla Insurance Costs Revealed: What 100+ Owners Pay by Model, Age, and Company

Hey everyone, DennisCW here! If you're a Tesla owner or thinking about joining the EV revolution, one of the biggest ongoing costs you'll face is insurance. In my latest video, I dove deep into real data from over 100 Tesla owners to uncover the cheapest insurance options. I asked about their monthly payments, insurance companies, states, models, and even ages to get a comprehensive picture. The results? Eye-opening insights that could save you hundreds—or even thousands—annually.

Whether you're a new owner shopping around or an existing one looking to switch, this breakdown will help you navigate the world of Tesla insurance. Plus, I've got some tips on saving money on your trade-in and must-have accessories. Let's break it down!

The Data: How We Collected It

I surveyed Tesla owners across the board and compiled the responses into our Tesla Insurance Tracker Sheet. It's a simple form where you can add your own info to help the community. Since my initial analysis, the dataset has doubled to over 100 entries! If you want to check out the raw data or contribute, click here to access the tracker. Sharing your details helps everyone find the best deals.

Cheapest Tesla Models to Insure

Based on the averages from our data:

• Model Y: $188/month (the cheapest overall)
• Cybertruck: $194/month
• Model 3: $196/month
• Model X: $197/month
• Model S: $200/month

These figures vary by factors like location and driver history, but it's clear the Model Y comes out on top for affordability.

Insurance Costs by Age Group

Age plays a huge role in premiums, especially for high-value vehicles like Teslas. Here's the breakdown:

• 45-54 years: $172/month (the sweet spot)
• 55+ years: $173/month (slightly higher, possibly due to limited data)
• Under 25 years: Significantly more expensive—expect to pay a premium if you're a younger driver.

Pro tip: As you get older, rates drop, but always shop around regardless of age.

Best (and Worst) Insurance Companies for Tesla Owners

This was one of the most surprising parts of the data. Some lesser-known companies offer killer deals:

• Dairyland: $117/month (the absolute lowest in our dataset)
• Geico: $158/month
• Mid-tier options: Costco, Tesla Insurance, State Farm
• Most expensive: Progressive, AAA, and surprisingly, Tesla Insurance again (it varies widely)

If you're with a pricier provider, it might be time to get quotes from these alternatives. One viewer shared: "This post got me motivated to call around for quotes on our four cars. Switching from Tesla Insurance to American Family/Costco Connect will save us $4,826 annually for the same coverage on a Plaid S, base Model 3, Performance Model 3, and a Rivian R1T." Real savings like that make this data invaluable!

Saving More on Your Tesla Journey

While we're on the topic of saving money, don't forget about trading in your current vehicle. Skip trading it to Tesla—use our partner Give Me The VIN instead. They buy from the comfort of your home and aim for maximum value. One viewer scored $3,000 more than Tesla's offer. Check it out here.

Also, keep an eye on global Tesla deals. In China, they're offering an enhanced discount of 4,000 yuan on the Model 3 rear-wheel drive. These incentives often start there and roll out to the US, so this could signal upcoming deals stateside. What do you think—let me know in the comments!

Must-Have Tesla Accessories

Your new Tesla comes with... nothing. No phone mount, no organizers—nada. But don't stress! Our partner Jowua has you covered with essentials like:

• A sturdy phone mount to keep your device secure during those quick accelerations.
• Center console organizers to prevent losing small items.
• An invisible under-screen station mount—perfect for sunglasses.

They even offer fun extras: a wireless game controller, portable air compressor, and an electric scooter for easy trips from chargers. I use their stuff daily, so I know it's quality. Use our promo code for savings, and get free shipping on orders over $120. Shop now and support the channel!

Final Thoughts

Insuring a Tesla doesn't have to break the bank. With averages around $188-$200/month depending on your model and age, and companies like Dairyland and Geico leading the pack, there's plenty of room to save. Contribute to the tracker, shop smart, and equip your ride with the right accessories. If this helped you, drop a like on the video, subscribe for more Tesla tips, and share your insurance story below.

What are you paying for Tesla insurance? Sound off in the comments!

Note: All data is user-submitted and averages may vary. Always get personalized quotes.