How to Score a Used Tesla for as Low as $171/Month: My Proven Strategy

How to Score a Used Tesla for as Low as $171/Month: My Proven Strategy

Hey everyone, DennisCW here! If you're dreaming of owning a Tesla but want the lowest payment possible, buying used might be your best bet. I've snagged deals on used Teslas myself—including my Model X with just 150 miles on it—and I'm breaking down my exact strategy to help you land one for potentially $171/month or less. Let's dive in!

Why Go Used? Do the Math First

New Teslas come with sweet financing at 2.99%, but used ones? You're looking at 5-7% interest. Used is ideal if you're paying cash or making a massive down payment.

Teslas (and EVs/luxury cars in general) depreciate hard in the first two years—often 50% off retail. Check this out:

• Cheapest in the US: 2020 Model Y for $14,500.
• 2022-2023 models: Around $25,000.
• Even 2024s dipping to $25k-$30k (originally $50k-$60k).

My sweet spot? 2 years old, ~25,000 miles. You still get 2 years/25k miles of the original 4-year/50k-mile warranty—transferable to any owner. Take it straight to Tesla for fixes, no hassle.

Where to Hunt for Deals

Skip the dealership markups. Here's my go-to list:

• Cars.com & CarGurus: Great for market values and tracking. Model 3s/Ys are holding steady right now—no big new model drops to tank prices.
• Facebook Marketplace (my #1): Private sellers! They're choosing between you or wholesalers like Plug. Offer $1k-$2k above their wholesale quote (e.g., Plug offers $29k? You bid $30k-$31k). Fast, transparent deals—especially if their new Tesla is incoming.
• Cars & Bids: Doug DeMuro's auction site for true market value.
• KBB/Edmunds: Check wholesale values before negotiating.

Market Update: Prices are flat in early 2025. Post-holiday, pre-tax season—no $4k used EV credit hype. Expect steady through spring.

Negotiation Tactics: Negotiate, Then Negotiate Again

1. Verify it's a real seller (not a lowball bot).
2. Ask: "Got any wholesale offers?" (Plug, CarMax, etc.).
3. Counter just above that—saves you thousands.
4. Be polite but firm. Sellers want quick closes.

Example: 2023 Model Y Long Range listed at $32k. Plug offers $29k? Offer $30k cash. Boom—deal!

Tesla's Used Leases: The Holy Grail

Tesla now offers used leases with insane payments like $171/month. They sold out fast last year, but check Tesla's pre-owned inventory regularly. Recent ones hovered at $250-$300. Patience pays off!

Pro Tip: New Tesla? Use My Referral

Buying new instead? Save up to $1,000 with my Tesla referral code. Link in the description below!

Protect Your Credit Before Financing

If financing, protect your credit first. Bank of America just had a data breach—they sat on it for a month! Companies take 277 days to report on average.

That's why I use Aura (today's sponsor). It scans the dark web for your info, kills spam calls, removes data from brokers, and includes $5M identity theft insurance. One clean app. Try it free for 14 days at aura.com/dennisw. Don't activate Sentry Mode after the damage—protect now!

Final Thoughts

Used Teslas are a steal if you play it smart—warranty intact, massive depreciation already baked in. Let me know in the comments: Hunting a specific model? Cash or finance? Drop your thoughts!

Subscribe for more Tesla tips, and check the description for Plug, referral, and Aura links. Drive safe!

—DennisCW