2023 Model Y used cars are sitting at $44,000 on CarMax for a base Long Range, exactly the same price as a new one with updated body, hardware and full self-driving capability included.
The numbers that make no sense
A four-year-old 2023 Model Y with 10k miles listed at $43,000 plus another with roof rack at $45,000. These are the 2023 Model Y used prices too high that everyone keeps scrolling past. When you stack them against a fresh Model Y Premium at $44,990 with newer everything, the math falls apart fast.
I ran the Tesla Model Y new vs used comparison myself and kept landing on the same conclusion: the used examples lose every time once you factor in the upgrades Tesla slipped into the current cars.
Why the used market still feels broken
Sellers are asking new-car money for older hardware that lacks the latest refinements. Even the Performance versions with flashy wheels do not justify the premium when a new non-Performance model already delivers better range and features out of the box.
That is exactly why the used Tesla Model Y prices insane buy new conversation keeps coming up. People see the CarMax listings, do the quick math, and realize they are better off ordering fresh.
The referral angle that changes the deal
Right now the Tesla referral — 3 months free FSD + low APR financing is still live. That free FSD referral deal alone is worth $2,500 and pairs perfectly with any new purchase. Used cars obviously cannot touch that incentive.
Counterpoint: when a used car might still work
Some buyers need to stay under a strict budget or want immediate delivery without waiting for inventory. In those narrow cases a clean low-mileage 2023 could make sense if the price drops another $5k–$6k. But right now those drops are not happening.
My take after running the numbers
The current window favors new inventory. Check Tesla Model Y inventory deals 2026 models are already appearing in some regions and the price gap only widens in favor of buying fresh. If you are comparing a 2023 used example to a new one today, the new car wins on features, warranty and the free FSD referral deal.
For the full breakdown see my deeper dive here: used Tesla Model Y prices insane buy new instead. If you want the step-by-step on current financing and referral timing, this post covers it too: tesla prices insane do this now.
Some links are affiliate links that support the channel at no cost to you.



